Brilliant peat bog video – plus C A Weber and Ageism

I’ve just been alerted to this great video about peat bogs and the argument for conserving them, featuring my good friends Mette Risager and Hans Joosten:

I was directed to it by Leonas Jarašius and his LIFE-Aukstumala team, who are engaged in establishing a major restoration and conservation programme for the legendary Aukstumala Bog in Lithuania and for which they have a great website. I was introduced to Leonas at the recent excellent Cumbria BogLIFE Conference and this link with Lithuania is now one of those happy spin-offs from that conference.
 
The Aukstumala Bog (or in former times also referred to as Augstumal Bog) is legendary because of this book:
 
weber-book
 
It was written more than a century ago but it should arguably still be used today as a core textbook for all peatbog scientists. The fact that it is not, highlights an increasing and worrying trend in modern science. There is a growing tendency in scientific academic circles (and academic teaching environments as well) to assume that papers or textbooks written much before the 1990s are somehow no longer relevant, are ‘out of date’, have passed their ‘sell by date’ and are thus discouraged or frowned on by the editors of today’s scientific journals or reviewers of university courses.
 
Few publications can demonstrate the profound error of this attitude more than C A Weber’s account of the Augstumal raised bog (modern-day Aukstumala raised bog) published in 1902 and translated illuminatingly into English by John Couwenberg, with additional edited information by John and Hans Joosten in 2002 – though now alas this excellent translated volume is out of print. This extraordinary monograph sheds light of great clarity on a great many aspects of raised bog ecology, yet little of what is written so lucidly by C A Weber more than 100 years ago is acknowledged – or even recognised – in today’s peatland scientific literature. We may be able to measure more elegantly, we may be able to investigate to finer levels of detail, but the fundamental understanding of ecological processes is not necessarily better – and indeed may often be very much worse – than the understanding which Weber sets out in his monograph. We need to remember that sometimes the past can illuminate just as much as the present.
 
munsary-2016-p1660637-adjusted-72dpi-50cm

Save

Myland wildlife, Colchester: 16th October 2016

The sunset was looking promising so I grabbed camera, tripod and folding stool and headed off into the fields. The sunset did not disappoint:
panorama-2-adjusted-72dpi-50cm
 
I arrived just in time because everything happened rather quickly. The glorious glow developed for perhaps 2 or 3 minutes:
panorama1-adjusted-72dpi-52cm
 
Then it quickly began to fade into shades of steel grey and blue:
panorama-3-adjusted-72dpi-50cm
 
Then I realised that there was another little show going on behind me – rather like a cloud-based aurora:
p1690306-adjusted-72dpi-1000px
 
By the time I turned back from this little display the last of the golden glow was fading, and it very quickly turned to inky darkness:
panorama-4-adjusted-72dpi-50cm
panorama-5-adjusted-72dpi-1300px
 
As I started packing up the camera in its bag, I realised that to the east the sky was developing into something equally spectacular, possibly somewhat illuminated by approaching moonrise:
panorama-6-adjusted-72dpi-1400px
 
Walking home back along the track which runs in the lee of a large hedge, I was suddenly dive-bombed by five or six bats. The light was terrible and they were scurrying round the sky like frantic winged mice, but I had a go at capturing something. Firstly, two examples of dots-that-are-bats:
p1690332-adjusted-72dpi-1000px
p1690339-adjusted-72dpi-800px
 
Then, amazingly and thanks also to the wonders of RAW imagery and Photoshop, a pair that swooped low over me, apparently sharing some news or something more substantial:
p1690348-adjusted-72dpi-900px
 
Sunsets and dive-bombing bats. It must be Halloween soon!

What the Commuter Saw: 12th and 13th October 2016

I still have a huge backlog of images from earlier commuter trips, including a journey up to Cumbria for the excellent Cumbria BogLIFE Conference, but the skies from the last couple of commuter journeys were interesting enough to merit a quick post now, then I can try to work back through a range of other journeys.
p1690051-adjusted-72dpi-850px
 
After several days of rather grey and miserable drizzly rain falling from thick layers of altostratus and nimbostratus, the skies on the 12th began to brighten. Layers of altocumulus stratiformis, with their little cloudlet streams, could just be spotted in the distance as the Abellio Greater Anglia train from Colchester to Stratford took us past Galleywood, west of Chelmsford:
p1690054-adjusted-72dpi-825px
 
The poplar field near Ingatestone now has a large herd of grazing cows, munching happily beneath the first glimpses of blue sky for a while:
p1690065-adjusted-72dpi-1000px
 
The Lone Oak to the east of Shenfield is surrounded by ploughed fields and is presumably dropping acorns in the thousands if the oak trees outside our house are anything to go by:
p1690078-adjusted-72dpi-29cm
 
Arriving at Gallion’s Reach DLR Station, the cumulus clouds bubbling up behind Canary Wharf were fairly impressive:
p1690084-adjusted-72dpi-1000px
p1690085-adjusted-72dpi-1000px
 
The journey home is alas going to be in the dark until next spring, so most photo-opportunities are restricted to the morning commute for the coming months. On the 13th, the layers of altostratus had finally cleared away to be replaced by banks of cumulus and altocumulus, giving some brilliant patches of sunshine over the Colne Valley weir:
p1690106-adjusted-72dpi-1000px
 
By the two poplars just west of Marks Tey the cloud cover had simplified into a single band of altocumulus giving many glimpses of blue sky above:
p1690137-adjusted-72dpi-1000px
 
The fields have been put down to grass or are ploughed – some very recently so:
p1690151-adjusted-72dpi-1000px
 
Vast tracts of fresh-ploughed soil now characterise the Essex landscape. Flocks of crows, rooks, wood pigeons and black-headed gulls plod methodically over the bare fields in search of worms and other soil fauna, or the fallen grains of wheat or barley which the gleaners (scroll to second poem in this link) would once have gathered:

'The White House' east of Witham
‘The White House’ east of Witham

 
By the fields west of Witham the bands of altocumulus to the north were starting to deposit rain over the distant landscape:
p1690176-adjusted-72dpi-1050px
 
And although New Hall School east of Chelmsford was bathed in bright sunshine, the cumulus behind it was fast building up into cumulonimbus capillatus with its drenching rain filling the darkness beneath:
p1690216-adjusted-72dpi-1050px
 
The banks of what was probably cumulonimbus calvus roiling out over Galleywood, just to the west of Chelmsford, were certainly spectacular:
p1690224-adjusted-72dpi-1075px
 
But there was no sign that they would combine or swell into anything more threatening. The cows grazing the fields west of Chelmsford enjoyed patches of bright sunshine:
p1690241-adjusted-72dpi-1025px
 
As did the herd in the poplar field near Ingatestone:
p1690260-adjusted-72dpi-1050px
 
Every now and again the sun would vanish behind a particularly thick bank of cumulus, as here near Billericay:
p1690266-adjusted-72dpi-1175px
 
But it would re-emerge into blue sky once more quite quickly. Consequently the Lone Oak east of Shenfield had a classic backdrop of white cauliflower cumulus:
p1690273-adjusted-72dpi-1000px
 
While the O2 Arena, seen from Canning Town DLR, had a fine collection of cumulus soaring overhead:
p1690280-adjusted-72dpi-1000px
 
The Cumbrian journey, and others, will hopefully (work permitting) be coming soon…

Professor Dicky Clymo – Valedictory Lecture

Last Wednesday I had the pleasure of listening to Dicky Clymo give a lecture at QMW University of London entitled “The life and afterlife of bog-moss: why does it matter?”:
 
p1690089-adjusted-72dpi-1000px
 
It was described as a Valedictory Lecture, although I suspect that Dicky is still a long way from hanging up his famous yellow oilskin waterproofs:
 

Dicky Clymo - Tierra del Fuego 2005
Dicky Clymo – Tierra del Fuego 2005

 
Tierra del Fuego 2005: Dicky Clymo an obvious feature of the landscape
Tierra del Fuego 2005: Dicky Clymo an obvious feature in the landscape

 
Dicky’s lecture was, as always, a master-class in how to turn the complicated into something simple and clear:
p1690090-adjusted-72dpi-28cm
p1690091-adjusted-72dpi-28cm
 
– in this case involving a couple of drinks bottles and a pair of miniature watering cans…
p1690093-adjusted-72dpi-28cm
 
…to demonstrate the way in which Sphagnum bog moss is able to acidify rainwater.
p1690098-adjusted-72dpi-29cm
 
But he was also able to make it clear that things which seem simple, such as his delightful animation of bog growth, can hide deeply complex processes.
 
Dicky Clymo at his best…

Agriculture (and nature conservation) post BREXIT: thoughts on this and on a review by Dieter Helm

It is one of the great ironies of the immediate post-war period that the Wild Life Conservation Special Committee, chaired initially by Dr Julian Huxley then by Sir Arthur Tansley, in producing Command 7122 Conservation of Nature in England and Wales (the first blueprint for statutory habitat conservation in England and Wales), failed to identify what would prove to be the greatest threat of all to the UK’s range of natural and semi-natural ecosystems – namely the mechanisation and intensification of agriculture.
 
In terms of habitat conservation, Command 7122 and its progeny The National Parks and Access to the Countryside Act 1949 were focused on the creation of nature reserves in which scientific research could be carried out on relatively natural ecosystems, while “scattered through the country [were] many small sites of considerable scientific importance”.
 
Command 7122, Section 214 was at pains to emphasise that these many scattered “Sites of Special Scientific Importance” (later to be termed “Sites of Special Scientific Interest” by Section 23 of the 1949 Act) would not stand in the way of development: It is not suggested that the existence of any such site should hold up plans for development, but that there should be machinery by which its existence could be made known at the earliest stage of planning so that such action as may be possible can be taken for its protection.
 
Farming practices, however, were not subject to planning control. One is left with the impression that the members of the Wild Life Conservation Special Committee retained a pre-war view of agriculture, a view of agriculture which, until the outbreak of war in 1939, looked remarkably similar to farming carried out a century or even two centuries earlier and in some cases dating back to pre-Norman times. These labour-intensive and in most cases manual practices gave rise to the rich diversity of habitats and species for which the UK countryside was famed and for which UK troops were urged to fight.
 
Your Britain - Fight for it Now [South Downs]
Your Britain – Fight for it Now [South Downs]© IWM (Art.IWM PST 14887)
 
Indeed a succession of committes sat through some of the darkest days of the war to frame the remit of the Wild Life Conservation Special Committee, but neither they nor the members of the Special Committee appear to have recognised that this landscape, which so many people were working or fighting to protect, was already vanishing because agriculture was undergoing a second agrarian revolution. Agriculture was mechanising and doing so at breathtaking speed because German U-boats were in danger of starving the UK into submission by sinking more than 3,500 allied merchant ships during what Churchill dubbed ‘The Battle of the Atlantic’. Indeed he later claimed that the only thing to have frightened him during the war was the U-Boat threat:
 
U Boote Heraus! [The U-boats Are Out!]
U Boote Heraus! [The U-boats Are Out!]© IWM (Art.IWM PST 0515)
 
So great was the danger of starvation and collapse that War Agricultural Executive Committees (War Ags) were established to encourage and enforce expansion of land under agriculture, with the result that the area of land under agriculture rose from a historic low of 5.2 million hectares in 1938 to almost 8 million hectares by 1945 – the largest area of arable land since formal records began to be collated in 1875 and representing a 50% expansion in just 5 years.
 
This expansion undoubtedly rescued the UK from starvation but still came at a huge environmental cost. Swathes of formerly unploughed ground, including chalk downlands of the type featured in the ‘Fight for it now’ poster, were put to the plough, while new chemical fertilisers such as nitro-chalk were added to the land to encourage grasses at the expense of rich wildflower communities and their associated extraordinary butterfly populations. Few farms possessed tractors before the war but by the end of the war most farms relied entirely on tractor power.
 
Post-war planning led to both the Agriculture Act 1947 and the National parks and Access to the Countryside Act 1949, but the provisions for habitat conservation contained within this latter Act, based as it was on Command 7122, provided little or no protection from the new force shaping the countryside – namely modern agriculture.
 
Jump forward almost 70 years across a relentless picture of declining habitats, declining invertebrate assemblages and declining bird populations, and the story of agriculture is picked up by Dieter Helm. The BREXIT vote has shaken many of the UK’s longest-established institutions, but potentially nowhere more so than the possible long-term effects on agriculture. After almost three-quarters of a century supported first by the UK Government and the once-mighty MAFF (now extinct), then by the even more mighty CAP (now heading for the divorce courts), it is not clear who in future will provide shelter for the agricultural industry nor what form the agricultural industry will be forced to take. I am not sure that Dieter’s paper has all the answers, but it certainly asks the right questions about the relationship between the environment, agriculture and land-use support mechanisms:
British Agricultural Policy after BREXIT
His paper can be read as a blog but it is also available as a downloadable PDF, which I find easier to read.
 

Myland wildlife, Colchester: 8th October 2016

Some catching-up to do in terms of commuter travel blogs and events, but for the moment this evening’s sunset was worth commenting on. After a fairly wet middle of the day, the clouds finally parted and produced a brief period of blue sky. This promised the possibility of an interesting sunset so I set off into the local fields. In the end the evening sky divided into various parts. To the west there was a thick band of low cloud which hid the final stages of sunset, above which half the dome of sky was streaked with high cirrus (click on images for full-screen view):
 
panorama-sunset-1-adjusted-72dpi
 
To the east the sky was largely just empty darkening blue, but to the north a thick bank of stratocumulus was moving rapidly across the sky:
 
panorama-dark-clouds-adjusted-72dpi
 
Just before the high cirrus was swallowed up by the bank of stratocumulus it burst out in a blaze of golden streaks:
 
panorama-streaks-1-adjusted-72dpi
 
The stratocumulus rapidly obscured everything and darkness settled across the landscape, but as I walked back home I spotted a round blob sitting on the telephone wires which cross the last field before emerging into Myland. The blob could only be an owl – specifically a Little Owl (Athene noctua – symbol of the Greek Goddess of Wisdom). I quickly set up the tripod because the darkness meant that only a long exposure would capture anything at all. In the end the owl was no more than a black blob on a dark background on the camera screen, but the magic of RAW and Photoshop revealed that this blob was indeed my acquaintance from a previous trip to these fields:
 
p1690043-adjusted-72dpi
 
A good way to end today’s visit to the fields.
 

Myland landscapes, Colchester : 15th September 2016

There’s been a few quite spectacular sunsets over Myland during the past week but alas there was no opportunity to capture these. Yesterday looked promising again. This time I was able to grab camera and tripod and walk out to the Myland fields in hopes of yet another spectacular sky. In the end it didn’t develop as I’d hoped because a thick bank of cirrostratus in the west blocked out the final stages of the sunset, but the high cirrus overhead nevertheless put on a fairly good show:
 
Panorama1 adjusted 72dpi
 
The wheat and barley have now gone, leaving just the stubble, and there’s a deeply earthy smell over the fields now:
P1680161 adjusted 72dpi
 
Watching the light fade in the west, there was suddenly a somewhat blood-curdling shrieking noise from the hedge half-way across the field – almost certainly a rabbit screaming – so perhaps there was a stoat or weasel hunting along the hedge-line. It all fell silent again as I watched the high cirrus spread like snowy dragons across the sky. The fact that this was disappointing compared to the sunsets from earlier in the week perhaps gives an idea of just how spectacular they were. But there will always be other sunsets…
Panorama2 adjusted from raw 72dpi
 
Click on the images to enlarge them; click back arrow on your browser to close the enlarged images.
 

Report : peat extraction and residual peat depth

Planning consent is required in the UK when commercial peat extraction takes place. One of the conditions imposed as part of any such consent relates to the after-use of the land.  Given the loss of lowland peat bog habitat both in Britain (e.g Lindsay & Immirzi, 1996) and elsewhere across Europe (e.g. Bragg & Lindsay, 2003), there is general recognition that peat bog sites subject to commercial peat extraction should have restoration to peat bog habitat as the prime target of after-use management.
 Bolton Fell Moss peat field small
The residual thickness of peat remaining at cessation of commercial extraction is a critical factor in determining whether bog conditions can be re-established immediately on the site or whether an extended (and often indeterminate) period of fen conditions will prevail before ‘ombrotrophic’ bog (i.e. rain-fed bog) conditions can re-establish. A concept frequently encountered in planning applications and consents is that of “an average minimum depth of 0.5 m” to remain as the residual peat depth at cessation of commercial working.
 
Scottish Natural Heritage commissioned us to examine the basis of this concept and determine whether available scientific evidence supported this concept or instead indicated that a different depth of residual peat is appropriate if the after-use objective and consent condition is for bog habitat to be re-established as quickly as possible.
 
Our review of the available scientific evidence indicates that there is no supported case for “an average minimum depth of 0.5 m”. Furthermore the available scientific evidence indicates that if the residual peat depth is less than 2 m then restoration is likely to lead to a vegetation which is essentially ‘poor fen’ rather than ‘ombrotrophic bog’, while the timescale for such poor fen to develop into true bog is unclear but likely to be measured in centuries rather than decades.
 
The key messages of our report, now available from SNH, are therefore that for new consents on sites where more than 2 m of peat remains across the site, planning consent should require that no part of the site (other than areas at the margins) be left with less than 2 m of peat. On sites where some parts of the site already have less than 2 m of residual peat, commercial extraction should cease at the earliest opportunity in order to minimise the extent and duration of poor-fen development.
 

Merlin Magic – colour illustrated edition, and update

Unfortunately the colour-illustrated edition of Merlin Magic has been removed from my Blurb Store window in error. It has now been re-instated with a new link:

Save

Furthermore, given the relatively high postage costs charged by Blurb for the purchase of individual books, I am investigating the possibility of selling the various editions (colour and b+w illustrated editions) direct through my own store linked to this website. This should significantly reduce postage costs for purchasers of individual volumes. I will post an announcement soon when I have investigated the mechanics of doing this.